Sunday, 6 April 2014

Madden's Parallel Lives I: Sir Anthony Standen



It is a fallacy of inestimable use to the commonplace historian, that in certain particular individuals may be delineated their times, every imprint of every compromise and confusion to be endured, read straight off like sap in a tree ring. But it is not only usefulness, nor convenience, nor even deep laziness that allows this false notion to thrive. The will comes into it more steadily and with greater power. Body and mind find such narratives hard to resist now, and we may, I propose, be sure it was as hard or more so in the past. Many human beings genuinely worthy of memory, true potential fulcra of study, who may indeed provide the keys to unexpected questions, remain, as it were, shrouded in their seeming suitability to their period. Thus the picturesque illustration of legend, accretion, assumption, overlays the evidence from which rightly conducted history derives her fatal substance.

This is what that consummate poser of lies and insomniac confessor of truths, Marshal Lermontov, meant when, condemning his Tsar to the rope, he smilingly called him ‘a hero of our time.’ Just such a hero, in his way, was, I propose, Sir Anthony Standen, secretary of state, ambassador extraordinary, most skilful, and least loyal, of the servants of Mary, Queen of Scots and of England. Skirted about by a typicality he exploited throughout his flexible, but finite career, he was in fact more idiosyncratic in his personal qualities and significance than any of his colleagues or adversaries had the wit to guess.

Standen – if we are to believe the hagiographies of his lifelong enemy, St Francis Walsingham – was born, in 1547, on the same day that saw Tyburn bespattered with the blood of that too-faithful Regent, the assiduous and ambitious Prince of the Church, the true founder of my sometime University, Royal Ipswich; Cardinal Thomas Wolsey. The Standens were a family of petty gentry who, indeed, grew up not far from the heart of Wolsey’s influence, living as they did in Molesey, the very sight of their eyes shadowed by the proximity of Hampton Court. Edmund Standen, esquire, was an equable soul indeed, never credited with any deed good or bad in his life, only with the acquisition of four sons, four daughters, and, presumably, the woman necessary for their generation. The little clan had never been anything but what they were, never learnt or worked or been heard of at any trade, accomplishment or activity whatsoever. Insofar as we trace them at all since the First Crusade took Glastonbury, it is as sensible, uncourageous mediators, and witnesses to the quarrels of their less predictable social superiors. The word ‘Surrey’ itself leadens the eyelid. The Standens of Surrey, until Anthony, brought eyelashes down like rusty portcullises.

Anthony was the first son, and it is one of the few insights that the conscientious historian possesses into the character and intellect of his father that one of his younger brothers was called Anthony, also, the other two, remaining still closer to the paternal Genius, being named Edmund. The four daughters’names do not come down to us in reliable forms, instead asserting their birthright to their mother’s and their ancestresses’ absolute obscurity; though it is not possible to disprove, either, the supposition that one might have been the ‘Bell Standing’ who made a cuckold of the Squire of Ditton in the 1580s. The first of the many poetic conveniences that both assist and strangely blur Anthony Standen’s memorability, is that both Edmunds remained in Molesey, just as both Anthonies sought wages, favour and fame on the wider stage of the state.

Mary, Queen of Scots had come into the inheritance of her cousin and namesake in 1558, at the age of sixteen, when the Standens were both unknown young country boys. By the time the two Anthonies entered the service of her cousin and favourite, young Lord Darnley, she had reigned from Westminster for some seven years, exercising a domestic policy distinguished by religious toleration and patronage of the arts, and a foreign policy that veered about drastically, depending on the disposition of her marriages. Her first husband, passed on with the rest of the kingdom by her defunct cousin, the previous Queen Mary, was King Ferdinand II of Spain; he had produced two sons, before succumbing to the bullet of a Protestant assassin. Alongside her second consort, Lord Leicester, Mary officially favoured the reformed religion, but she still liked the company of Catholic gentlemen about her, purporting to consider their conversation more amusing. Thus were made the careers of Darnley and the Standen brothers, all lissom Papist youths not yet in their twenties. The elder Anthony was named as Darnley’s esquire, the younger his cupbearer.

Robert Fleetwood, an older court figure who disapproved of the direction affairs were taking under Lord Leicester’s influence, wrote a secret report in October, 1566, to the chancellery of France, which gives us a brief impression of the elder Anthony’s importance to and influence over young Darnley:

His Lordship’s head is quite hollowed out, as it might be the shell of a peascod, though its outer habiliments indeed possess such a sheen as to beguile forth a Queen’s gentleness. Yet withal, this Darnley is too poor a figure to play even, with over much success, the soldier; all the same, he would be taken for a master of poesie, a lutanist, a philosophical antiquarie, and I know not how much else. In all this does the elder Ant. Standen, a quick and serpentine intelligencer, stand his fast and indisseverable accomplice; so that, perchance, if he and the said Standen are some day at bowls, and the Queen’s coming is heard abroad, hie will they from her path, and this Standen doth strum and swither upon the virginall or suchlike instruments. ‘What lists thou there,’ asks the Queen, and ‘ho,’ say her ladies, with never a glance astray, ‘that is your fair cousin, Your Majesty, young Lord Darnley labouring as ever on your pleasure.’ And the Queen smiles as though well pleased; only to my lords Leicester and Lethington might she murmur, ‘I know very well it is indeed this Anthony, and not young Caesar, who so plaieth at my heart.’ For the Queen so dubs young Darnley, never forgetting how near he bideth to her blood and throne.

Fleetwood exaggerates both the Queen’s suspicion of her cousin and her admiration for his servant, to please his French paymasters; but there seems little doubt that the elder Anthony was widely considered as a luminous ‘man of parts’, esteemed as that rare thing, a reliable wit.

Of the younger Anthony, the stories were rarely as creditable. The playwright Edmund Campion may have had him in mind as the figure of Ganymede, in his 1570s pageant The Joviall Feaste Daye, and St Francis Walsingham – as we have already seen, no unprejudiced source – calls him outright the catamite of Darnley. For our, or at any rate my, purposes, the young Standen figures chiefly as a wearying encumbrance to the interpretation of his more able elder brother’s fiscal obligations. Anthony the younger’s death is recorded without unanimity as to time or cause, but universally placed at ‘The Ravenscote’, an inn on the Southbank usually regarded as an insalubrious and ambiguous erotic resort.

For all the elder brother’s talents and rising fame, Standen’s career at court was soon to go awry for reasons quite out of his power to predict or evade. His master Lord Darnley grew up, unexpectedly, as an increasing partisan of Leicester, who might have been expected to regard him as an amatory threat, but instead wisely made of the self-regarding lordling a pet and a toy. It was by Leicester’s hand that Standen was knighted, so that he might have sufficient rank to bear an ultimatum to the governor of Spanish Ireland in 1575. But while he was still at sea news reached him that the Queen had divorced Lord Leicester, hurling into bastardy their little son Prince Ambrose, in order to marry her husband’s nephew, Sir Philip Sidney. When in short order word followed that Lord Darnley had been found hanged in circumstances beyond comprehension or even decent consideration, Standen thought it wisest to find a pretext to stay abroad. He sought and received a commission to find a husband for Queen Mary’s eldest son among the princes of Italy.

Matters are again complicated by the fact that the younger Standen, his inglorious nemesis still some years ahead of him, seems to have visited Venice for a brief but very extravagant period at about this time, judging by certain outraged statements in the Vendramin Correspondence. This has misled some authorities into confecting an idea that the elder Standen was ambassador to Venice, which cannot have been so given his known movements on the mainland of Italy. As I have discussed elsewhere, Sir Anthony, as he now was, must have landed at Pisa, and progressed in leisurely steps to the court of the Medici, at Fiesole.

To this itinerary, I do not hesitate to state even if I cannot in all mundanity prove, we owe the most exquisite material and visual legacy Sir Anthony left behind him in all his many travels, Bronzino’s Portrait of a Briton in a Green Doublet, which I was lately the first, and indeed am still the only authority to attach to Standen’s name and journeying. I have, however, achieved my object in offering this suggestion, which was in fact to demonstrate the combination of verbal prolixity and logical paucity which tends to infect any of my colleagues when faced with the novel. Give us documents, they say, give us ledgers, lie columns of figures at the steel-shod toes of the great goddess Provenance. Well, why should I, when a severer force and motive is my employer and spur? What is Mentor, when opposed to Moira? Look at the long face, the crooked angle of Bronzino’s Briton, the sunburn that resembles a light wound bleeding beyond expectation. Look at the small eyes and the anxious lunge after fashion, for all the penance of sweat; and recall, if you will, that to wear green at court was an ancient perquisite of the Squires of Molesey.

Standen had presence of mind that never deserted him, and he was now besides at the pinnacle of his solvency, repute, and, the Bronzino taken as read, somewhat unconventional but undoubted physical charm. Yet his mission, to find a bride for young Charles of Hapsburg, Prince of Wales and Scotland, was foiled almost at once, by an unforeseen but ineluctable form of sabotage. She was a form with a name, one that had snared a great magnate in its time – Barbara von Blomberg, who had once been the ‘handfast wife’ of the Emperor Philip the Grim. Exhausted by that worthy but oppressive monarch’s religiose determination – which did not quite extend to domestic matters – Barbara, originally a mezzo-soprano singer from Regensburg, had determined to enjoy more varied fruits throughout her briefly lamented late protector’s dominions. She was thus a kind of aunt-out-of-marriage of the young prince whose prospects were under discussion; and she was determined to bring them to ruin. Besides, like many of his acquaintance before and afterward, she seems to have a taken a real liking to Standen.

These atavistically simple relations were, however, not a little entangled by the unfortunate coincidence that Farinata de’ Medici, Prince of Fiesole, also aspired to the enchanting Barbara’s bed. It should be noted in a spirit of proportionate admiration that Frau von Blomberg was at this point almost fifty years of age. However it may be, Prince Farinata and his wife Ginevra were declared to be dead at the hand of an unknown poisoner on the same day. Ginevra then recovered long enough to place the sole blame on the Prince, who, shocked out of his own stupor, blamed Blomberg. Standen’s name went unmentioned during the scandal, but in point of fact he and Blomberg had both departed long since, bound back for the familiar disputed territory of Spanish Ireland. The predominant emotions provoked by the whole unedifying story must, surely, be surprise and regret that Bronzino never depicted Blomberg.

Not that la Blomberg, however, passed her eventful days altogether unimmortalised, if my suspicions, and their foundations, whether empirical, circumstantial, or esoteric, may be trusted. It is my contention that the eighth shorter sonnet sequence of John Knox, which is often acknowledged to include a certain amount of spurious material, also contains one verse of a standard equal to the great Scotch Bard’s, but in quite a distinct strain. Following several intimations within (and behind) the text itself, I propose that this remarkable little poem is that very scarce treasure, a lyric in English at a court of the Rinascimento.

                        Stay, fatal empress, for that all thy fame
                        Dearer than spikenard’s breath or honour’s self
                        Firmer in sway and hardier in health
                        Embanners thee, e’en so, belay thy game
                        Of Catilines and catkins of the same
                        What cares the Panther for the corse’s pelf
                        Who suck and nourishes gore unto health
                        And martiall Destinie accords the lame?

Catiline, of course, is a reference to the Consul and Triumvir of that name, murderer of the philosopher Cicero and generally disdained in poetic tradition, who won his greatest victory at Fiesole. The author addresses a lady as ‘empress’ with such wheedling insistence that a definite impression is conveyed that she is not truly of such, or any similar, rank, but that regal and imperial titles nevertheless have some meaning in her past, or milieu. Furthermore, the final lines seem to indicate an amoral, but not unimpressive personal credo that favours homicide above conventional inheritance, and considers the victim’s plight superior to the dependant position of the comfortable invalid. We may note, at this point, that Prince Farinata, like many Medici, was rendered almost immobile by rickets.

                        Such limbes as thou has cast over this board,
                        Such as commingle with black art and eyes,
                        Of travail, more than trusting, I forethought,
                        And likewise did forswear the em’rald sward
                        Steeled, for fresh the path, but fell the rise
                        All that thy woundings and thy gait have taught.

The sonnet has, of course, been commonly read as a rather stilted and literal account of the famous moment when John Knox abandoned his minister’s calling and entered the service of Queen Mary, smitten, as a surprising number of eyewitnesses avouch, by her sheer physical immaculacy. But I would counter that the muse of this poem is no immaculate, not the sort of woman who would extract the tribute of fawning hyperbole from even a renegade priest. On the contrary, she appears, unashamedly, to be a conscious bad lot, committed to a perilous course and only attractive – irresistible, even? – to a particular sort of worldly, self-deceived man of affairs. Beside the Catiline reference, I maintain that this is quite sufficient a pedestal on which to erect those unusually matched inammorati, Sir Anthony Standen and Frau Barbara von Blomberg.

The new governor of Spanish Ireland was Don John, son of la Blomberg and the Emperor Philip, who had been named to the position as banishment rather than reward, to punish him for his disastrous defeat by the Turks at Lepanto. His mother thus expected a kindly reception in Dublin for both herself and her new attachment. The journey took them, however, at first overland, through Spain, where Standen posed as a dealer in pictures, adopting the whimsical name of Pompeio Pellegrini. The Duchess of Medina Sidonia attests in her recollections that the disguise was a thin one, for ‘Signora Pellegrini’ much resented remaining incognita in a land where she had once been received with almost imperial honours.

It was, however, shortly before the Pellegrini pair were to set sail for Cork from Cadiz that Standen succeeded in passing to a Scots agent, Buchanan (no relation of the poet and grammarian), a letter admitting his true identity and assuring Lord Lethington, Queen Mary’s Secretary of State, of his continuing allegiance and loyalty, despite ‘any outward apparition or appurtenance of obeisance to any potentate of Spayne or of Erse partes’. This communication was a well-proportioned example of Standen’s deviousness and ingenuity, for it was itself concealed in a ‘Pompeio Pellegrini’ missive purporting to offer the Queen first refusal on certain items in the estate of Giorgione, the supreme Venetian painter who had just perished at a great age.

A gap then settles, itself indicative of Standen’s rigorously adaptable temperament, for Sir Anthony is next heard of in 1588, on the staff of the victorious Earl of Essex. Essex had just routed Don John and the Spanish from Ireland after showing himself to be remarkably familiar with the disposition of their forces. Barbara von Blomberg, a survivor out-survived, vanishes from any subsequent record; and it seems to me regrettably certain that Standen only returned to his royal mistress after definitively ridding himself of his quasi-imperial one.

The Queen had, during Sir Anthony’s adventures abroad, outlasted Sidney and two subsequent husbands, the Earl of Oxford and Sir Walter Raleigh. It seems that Lethington now counselled her to pre-empt any threat from her victorious commander Essex’s popularity, by adding him to this roll of honour; and the sudden rise of Standen upon the Queen’s sixth and, as it would turn out, final marriage leaves us in little doubt that his operations were among those that greased the progress of the match. 1589 saw his appointment to the delicate but lucrative Embassy Extraordinary to Paris; his first duty was to ensure the continued enmity of France towards Spain, and vice versa. It is, then, another scarcely – but unavoidably – credible instance of his complex character, that a Venetian ambassador informed his government that, three months into the Paris post, Sir Anthony covertly but personally involved himself in yoking the Dauphin to an Infanta. This intrigue could have no other name than treason, and yet it was to redound to the greater glory and security of Britain’s government, and, more immediately, enable the further ascent of Standen himself.

For it was not the Ambassador Extraordinary who seemed to most to bear the blame for this fatal combination of enemies, not the Queen, nor her new husband, but the longest-lasting genius of her council, her Secretary of State, the faithful Lethington. His execution led to his protégé Standen’s immediate recall, not for a reprimand, but for a promotion into his master’s boots. Francis Bacon in discreet company quipped ‘that Sir Anthony had enjoyed an untroubled crossing indeed, upon the fair wind of his Friend’s last Breaths.’

The hostile powers of the continent still threatened a time of dire and unavoidable war, but to the fertile invention of Standen, and the unscrupulous resolve of his new patron Essex, the solution was ready to hand. At home the noise was all of pipe and drums and martial footfall; and in a bitter war to the end, Essex and Standen’s men suggested, who was the better monarch, a lecherous old woman or a virile, proven young warrior? Abroad, their agents dripped speeches of syrup, and dangled an irresistible, if humiliating gift – the total reversal of the Protestant Reformation which had been so close to the hearts of both Queen Maries.

So it was that Queen Mary of Scotland and England, six times a wife and six a mother, fosterer of her country’s Golden Age of letters, muse of Shakspere and Spencer and Knox and many another, spent the last thirteen years of her too long reign confined in the Tower of Westminster, while the Regent Essex closed her graceful, humane age, and inaugurated the iron successes of his country in naval warfare. Standen did not last long enough to see his bloody crop’s whole harvest. He died before his fiftieth year, in 1594, of an excessive bleeding of his own, induced by his physicians. He had given every appearance of fashioning his age, but it instead has crafted him, a quick-footed, bright eyed, empty doublet, in green velvet despite the perpetual hot season. Sir Anthony left no definite issue, though the Chancellery was forced at intervals to buy the discretion of purported Blomberg bastards. His funeral was well attended, and commemorated in one of Tallis’s more forgettable compositions, an unwise collaboration with Greene.

Tentative intro to Disappointing Sons



Consider two great twentieth century poets, Yeats and Larkin, on a theme that has long preoccupied their art: heredity. In the aftermath of an Oxford college gaudy – half-tedious, half-voyeuristic events, floating between one of poetry’s driving forces, nostalgia, and a mundane, institutionalised form of social embarrassment – Larkin contemplates a contemporary’s reduplication, and his own sudden sense of fin de race. His disbelief is all the sharper for being sleepily expressed:

…To have no son, no wife,   
No house or land still seemed quite natural.   
Only a numbness registered the shock   
Of finding out how much had gone of life,   
How widely from the others. Dockery, now:   
Only nineteen, he must have taken stock
Of what he wanted, and been capable
Of ... No, that’s not the difference: rather, how

Convinced he was he should be added to!
Why did he think adding meant increase?
To me it was dilution.

Part of the poet’s uneasy surprise relates to his feeling of being outflanked by Dockery, a father at a drastically young age, according to a piece of mental arithmetic roughly applied, but, as the poem proceeds, increasingly accepted. Then there’s the way in which Larkin implies he has associated Dockery, younger than the poet as he may have been, with an older, decadent class. Without ever stooping to that hoary adjective ‘callow’, he leaves it as Dockery’s lasting impression; there is a touch of the elegiac Raymond Asquith myth about the sparse, deliberately uncertain single descriptive query:

                                                                …Was he that withdrawn

High-collared public-schoolboy, sharing rooms
With Cartwright who was killed?

It is a question mark more terse than true. The reader feels that Larkin remembers Dockery more specifically than he is entirely willing to admit. The sartorial detail lends an impressionistic touch of visual reality; further, it combines with the class indicator to let us imagine the relationship between Larkin and this ‘junior’ contemporary pretty fully. Clothes are revealing; Widmerpool in Anthony Powell’s A Dance to the Music of Time never escapes his ill-fitted lapels. But this high collar is an object not so much of ridicule as of suspicion, and something approaching envy. There is a reason why the Dean of the College has brought up Dockery, a vague association, to this middle-aged visitor he hardly, and discreditably, recalls. Larkin’s most notable encounters with the Dean have, it seems, been disciplinary:

…Or remember how   
Black-gowned, unbreakfasted, and still half-tight   
We used to stand before that desk, to give   
‘Our version’ of ‘these incidents last night’?   

Dockery, on the other hand, well-born, heeled, and behaved, was likely a favourite even back in the day, and now he is a respected Old Member, father of an undergraduate the Dean can call to mind and perhaps has called to tea, quite possibly a donor to the college.
Who, by contrast, is Larkin? As he himself now realises, in the Dean’s eyes and his own, a mere composite of negatives, ‘no son, no wife, / No house or land’. What he has is ‘nothing with all a harsh son’s patronage’: including the patronage of Dockery’s son, which perpetuates a previous generation’s de haut en bas victory over Larkin. Dockery’s son is boasted about to passing graduates; Larkin’s departure is unsung (‘I catch my train, ignored’). The poem sounds the note of resentment against undergraduate toffs fresh from ‘Lamprey College’ that we hear throughout Larkin’s first novel, Jill. But it is a wiser and a sadder work. It tells us about Larkin’s automatic attitude to the tragedy he sought, notoriously, to sidestep,

                        Get out as quickly as you can
                        And don’t have any kids yourself.

- that of parenthood. More honestly, it reveals the steps by which the poet comes to regret this barren strategy of damage limitation – and to envy the unanticipated success of his societal nemesis, Dockery. The first syllable after Larkin hears of Dockery the younger’s existence is a translucent slice of his thought – ‘death’. He is prepared by more than funeral costume to enter a sombre mood. Reflections pass in the imperfect tense – ‘we used to stand’ ‘where I used to live’. Thoughts of death and the British railway’s motion drive him to escape in sleep, but as he wakes for the change of trains, his bafflement has begun to shift to mourning.
Larkin makes a remarkable debating point now: what made Dockery so sure he was perpetuating himself, not robbing it? ‘To me it was dilution.’ His defensive fear of reproduction is unusually frankly put, sincerely felt. This is not without its relationship, as we shall see, to the views on the same subject of an unlikely, mid-to-late-life father, Yeats (the paternal influence, pleasingly, behind Larkin’s early poems). Reproduction, and implicitly sex, as a sap on literary power makes us think of atavistic superstition, clerical celibacy, succubi. Dockery, whose function is to carry on dynasties, pass on lands, endow colleges, but certainly not to write poems, can have no such scruples. Larkin begins to wonder if the high-collared public-schoolboy was right. Did he, Larkin, squeamishly adhere too closely to some undergraduate reaction – cast aside a life for a pose?

…Where do these
Innate assumptions come from? Not from what   
We think truest, or most want to do:
Those warp tight-shut, like doors. They’re more a style   
Our lives bring with them: habit for a while,
Suddenly they harden into all we’ve got

And how we got it…

The defensiveness continues in that ‘we’; Dockery’s reproduction, the poet says, is quite as irrational, habitual and therefore accidental, as his own lack of it. But this equivalency fails to account for the difference between a positive and a negative. ‘Got’, unexpectedly repeated line to line, stanza to stanza, comes to suggest its archaic meaning,

                        And now you shall be as your mother was
                        When your sweet self was got.
                        (Shakespeare, All’s Well that Ends Well, IV.ii)

and so the poem arrives at its final dichotomy: ‘For Dockery a son, for me nothing.’ A son, not a child; childless Larkin may be, childless he remained, but the voice he uses here, the antithesis and also the unsuccessful shadow of Dockery, thinks in, and secretly yearns for, patriarchal and almost feudal forms of contented settlement and succession – house, land, wife, son.
            For Yeats, on the other hand, in the fourth section of Meditations in time of Civil War, dynastic duty has entailed – to use that word advisedly – producing genetic tribute of both genders –

Having inherited a vigorous mind
From my old fathers, I must nourish dreams
And leave a woman and a man behind
As vigorous of mind…

Perhaps the kindly, encouraging, and ineffectual talent of Jack Yeats has meant that his son at the outset perceives his own gift in more generous terms than Larkin’s fear of ‘dilution’. While Larkin toys with the idea that it is not so much the poet’s responsibility as his right not to reproduce, hoarding a power inexplicable in its origin and elusive in its retention, Yeats acknowledges a time-honoured debt. This must be paid not merely in ‘a son’ – that is, a singular copy, subjectively related, and a repeat of one’s own gender – but in ‘a woman and a man’, two generic human beings objectively if immodestly up to scratch (‘As vigorous of mind’), and, in some instinctual, incestuous and, probably, eugenic manner, of opposite genders, constituting a breeding population. But the debt is not, in fact, just to John Butler Yeats the artist. The plural of ‘fathers’ reaches to a recurring concern of Yeats’s, both individual and impersonal – dynasty and domain. This is the same patch of associations, perhaps, as Larkin’s son, wife, house, and land, but whereas Larkin imagines this field bemusedly and belatedly, Yeats takes it seriously and consistently. He would certainly have included in his ‘fathers’ – perhaps primarily – his mother’s family, the Pollexfens, richer than the Yeats, less Bohemian, more rural and Anglo-Irish, simply more landed. But it is not only his own blood that sirs him to think of descent and obligation. To Yeats any place is bound to families that hold it, or once did. Architecture stimulates him most when doused in blood. Here is the beginning of Blood and the Moon –

Blessed be this place,
More blessed still this tower;
A bloody, arrogant power
Rose out of the race
Uttering, mastering it,
Rose like these walls from these
Storm-beaten cottages…

Building and breeding seem to have become of necessity entwined for Yeats. Had he written An Arundel Tomb, it would have been a celebratory affair fading into genetic dark, not an ironic meditation with an artistic redemption at the end. His art was subordinated in his mind to the stuff that made him.
            So far, then, divorced from his fellow ‘Last Romantic’, Yeats goes on in the My Descendants section to betray a distinct but related terror to Larkin’s twin fears, of dilution and extinction. In fact, Yeats is troubled by an inverted variant on Larkin’s contempt for ‘high-collared, withdrawn’ Dockery – he worries his children might become Dockerys, unworthy of the collective legacy he has transmitted:

And what if my descendants lose the flower
Through natural declension of the soul,
Through too much business with the passing hour,
Through too much play, or marriage with a fool?

‘Marriage with a fool’ is a phrase with particular bite, which Yeats would recycle by 1936, expressing his equivocal feelings about another descendant of his generation – Iseult Gonne:

            A girl that knew all Dante once
Live to bear children to a dunce.

Yeats had proposed to Iseult in 1916, directly after a courteous and partly symbolic proposal to and rejection by her mother, Maud. His feelings about Iseult were in appearance and in fact distinctly mixed; the girl lived as Maud’s niece, was in truth her daughter, and may have represented to Yeats the daughter he and Maud could have had. This is after all a common fancy in the aftermath of writerly and unrequited passion; see Charles Lamb, Dream Children: A Reverie:

We are not of Alice, nor of thee, nor are we children at all. The children of Alice called Bartrum father. We are nothing; less than nothing, and dreams. We are only what might have been, and must wait upon the tedious shores of Lethe millions of ages before we have existence, and a name.

Whatever wistfully filial emotions Yeats entertained for Iseult, he was quick to transmute them into enough romantic fervour to propose to her; and indeed to remain preoccupied by her days into a honeymoon with another woman. Such vicarious love for the daughter of a muse is as well known a syndrome as vicarious fatherhood. David Garnett succumbed to the sentiment at about the same time as Yeats, with his immediate reaction to the child of his lover Duncan Grant and Vanessa Bell: ‘I think of marrying it. When she is 20, I shall be 46 – will it be scandalous?’ (He did and it was.) The lovers of Lorna Garman, Laurie Lee and Lucien Freud, less directly married her nieces. At any rate, to marry or seek to marry the descendant, even collateral, of a lost love expresses a faith in genetics that verges upon the religious. Yeats, in considering his son or daughter’s union to an unknown and unworthy future in-law, and Iseult’s to the lightweight journalist Francis Stuart in 1920, automatically equates ‘marriage’ with the act ‘to bear children.’ The concern is entirely scientific and not sacramental, but for all that, under Yeats’s handling, it appears no less superstitious. What is that unadorned ‘flower’ in danger of loss? Something, obviously, that can be squandered simply by ‘bearing children’ to the wrong stock; and yet, the previous stanza’s syntax would seem to equate it with Yeats’s own ‘vigorous mind’; all of his own poet’s power, that is, and all the (albeit somewhat notional) aristocratic power of his ancestors. Yeats’s whole self, and more than that self – the aboriginal past to which he maintains it owes its being – is staked, not even on his own, but on his children’s prospect of successful heredity.
            Yeats is superstitious, too, or rather, occult, in his curse in the event of that heredity’s failure:

May this laborious stair and this stark tower
Become a roofless ruin that the owl
May build in the cracked masonry and cry
Her desolation to the desolate sky.

Indeed, when we think of Larkin’s malaise induced by his childless state, it begins to seem that the later poet somehow fell under the very curse the earlier one pronounced. For both, the presence of children relates to the solidity of property and architecture. But Yeats gives a visible, even stagey incarnation to what becomes Larkin’s empty, broken litany, ‘To have no son, no wife, / No house or land’. The most important difference is that Larkin’s bleak void is the result of no descendants, while Yeats’s almost lush Gothic fantasy of disrepair, the owl borrowed from Christabel and the atmosphere from Macbeth, is a vision designed to punish descendants because they have existed and failed. But the sense of insult Yeats feels towards these hypothetical wastrel offshoots, personal and artistic, and at the same time familial and conventional, is not, perhaps, so far from the powerful negative motive, fear of ‘dilution’, that keeps Larkin out of the shooting-match altogether until what he feels is too late.
            If My Descendants was a genuinely freestanding poem, instead of a nuanced movement within the more complicated shape of all Meditations in a Time of Civil War, then the final stanza would, as a conclusion, ring false. Larkin, on the other hand, through Dockery & Son gropes closer towards frank admission of regret.

Tuesday, 10 December 2013

Fair Helen (for review 31)


The title page of Andrew Greig’s latest novel Fair Helen announces that we have to deal with ‘a veritable account of “Fair Helen of Kirkconnel Lea”, scrieved by Harry Langton’. This may seem of a piece with the unpretentious gorgeousness of the dust-jacket and the faintly Tolkienian map of ‘the Borderlands’. But Harry Langton is a necessary as well as an enjoyable creation. Without him, Greig might find himself exposed in this intimidating territory, a retelling of one of the most famous Border ballads collected by Sir Walter Scott. Fair Helen of Kirkconnel Lea’s qualities of simplicity, melody and drama have, indeed, set it in better stead today than most of Scott’s novels. To sing a ballad as it was meant to be sung is a clear, if not necessarily an easy, task; to expand upon its themes in fiction is more dangerous. Greig risks affronting both the shade of Scott and the tradition Sir Walter purported to preserve. Harry Langton, ‘scrivener, spy, side-kick, lover, betrayer’, is the mask behind whom Greig can conceal the audacity of his grave-robbery.

But if Langton were only a mask, he would be worn to little purpose. His language, his location, his physicality and mortality conspire to deliver him as a peculiarly incarnate presence. ‘Ane doolie sessoun…’,[1] the first chapter heading murmurs, quoting Henrysoun - a poet consigned to the glorious past even within the past of the novel itself, clinging on amid Langton’s mental lumber. The scattered inflections of Langton’s Lallans convey his period and atmosphere with style, tact, and a playful glossary; but above all, they act as an engine of characterisation. Here is an educated old man, tetchy, adrift, retained as ‘a relic of lang syne’, a professional nostalgic catering to the romantic sensibility of his cultivated, modern patron.

That patron is William Drummond of Hawthornden, whose castle still offers shelter to writers today, but whose poetry is now, as Langton continually and snidely predicts, largely forgotten. It is Langton, Drummond’s picturesque old librarian, as stubbornly loyal to the ethos of Lucretius and Montaigne in his mind as to the language of Henrysoun on his tongue, who seems to us the more far-seeing. By dangling his narrator so neatly between two Scots poets – Henrysoun, indigenous, demotic, vital; Drummond, cosmopolitan, courtly, mannered – Greig makes his own sympathies clear. But he also avoids making Langton a mere spokesperson, a man ahead of and therefore alien to his own time.

Although (to over-simplify) a middle-class bisexual atheist at odds with his age, Langton is made so for detailed and convincing reasons; his mother was a gentlewoman married into ‘Embra’ city folk, while his university education deepens his ambiguities of rank and habit. He is stuck in a life he finds demeaning and a country estranged, ‘now the Kingdoms are united and the Court gone south’. ‘My breath puffs clouds as I scrape clear the garret window, ice slivers melt under yellowed fingernails…What remains of my right hand is warm in wool, as are my feet and scrawny thrapple.’ This is not a narrator cribbing his appearance to the reader over his shoulder, but a done man, counting his faculties.

‘I had not seen Adam Fleming since his mother’s wedding. He had been silent and inward then, remote across the crowded hall. Tall, slim, and agile, in his black cloak of grieving for his father…dagger in embroidered pouch…’ We too have met young Fleming before, though in our world, as CS Lewis says of Aslan, he has another name. What Greig does with Hamlet in Fair Helen is at first disorienting; at worst we might even suspect the arrival of historical fiction’s hackney carriage, neither ordered nor intended. The blurb should set us right, though: ‘The legend often called the Scottish Romeo & Juliet…brilliantly re-presented as the source of an equally famed, more complex drama’. So that’s all right, then: but, as with the ghost of Henrysoun and the loom of Drummond, there is more at work here than arch allusion. Adam the Dane, or Hamlet Fleming, will eventually lead us to one of the best bookish jokes in a novel full of them. But at first, he invites an assumption. Langton and Fleming, his ‘dearest friend’, were fellow undergraduates at Edinburgh, ‘the city, the courts, the college where we had once disputed fine points with words and argument, not the finer point of dagger and short sword’. ‘He had been effortlessly good with racquet, rapier and small pipes, while I was a dogged trier.’ Greig seems to have chosen – as Hamlet did before him – Horatio as his narrator.

But in this Hamlet we are treated to scenes in Wittenberg, or ‘Embra’, alma mater of Langton, Fleming, and Greig himself. Evoked at first in shared jokes, French tags and kestrel cries, the memory of university days becomes, more and more, the key to the novel’s central relationship (one that easily eclipses that of Fleming and the titular damsel). Edinburgh University in the latter 16th century is an arena where the otherness and drama of history, high politics and the High Renaissance can mingle with knowing, familiar accounts of undergraduate existence, flirting with anachronism without tainting the whole. Fleming and Langton, languid gentleman and infatuated swot, are not wholly free of Sebastian and Charles, but this does them no harm. The pair’s dreams of travel and adventure as they climb the hills above the city at night could come from any time – ‘We could rent a house by the Tiber, live by translation and scrivening! We would gather news and gossip, live on a retainer from the King. He said I would make an excellent spy.’ Yet these half-baked small hours schemes are historically specific – the King is donnish young ‘Jamie Saxt (but six years our elder)’ – and come to have proleptic impact on the plot. Hamlet had more than one schoolfellow, and Langton, seemingly Fleming’s loyal Horatio, is actually more of a Rosencrantz, manoeuvred by the hidden, powerful hand that feeds him. ‘I was not quite the free man my friend imagined.’

The identity of Langton’s paymaster is another of Greig’s post-modern, Early Modern jokes – it is Sir Walter Scott. Not quite, indeed, the baronet of the ballad, but his collateral ancestor, Scott of Buccleuch and Branxholme, a notorious reiver who adapted superbly to the Union of the Crowns, became the King’s proxy in the Borders, and founded a ducal dynasty. If Fair Helen were Wolf Hall, this Scott would be its hero; seen instead from outwith himself, he casts a pall of pleasing noir. ‘Among these hot-headed, impulsive, unbridled warrior lairds, he seemed cool as a well-run pantry.’ Langton is particularly fluent on the subject of Scott’s eyes – ‘pale and shining as a coulter blade’. ‘I felt myself a mouse running before them, twisting and turning from their edge…I felt a grue pass through me like a chill wind shaking a field of grain. He had seen too well where I was going.’

No traditional interpretation links Sir Walter Scott, 1st Lord Scott of Buccleuch, to the story of Fair Helen of Kirkconnel Lea, but Greig’s leap here is, geographically and politically speaking, as plausible as it is devious. The Annandale scene, as Langton observes, is tiny: ‘Embra apart, one could ride to any of the principal locations…within the hour. Aristotle would approve.’ The events that inspired the ballad are bald and visceral – the heir of Fleming met the heir of Bell, in a duel over the heiress of Irvine; she fatally threw herself in the way of Bell’s bullet, whereupon Fleming killed Bell, indeed according to the ballad ‘hacked him in pieces sma’’. The contentions of land in this story are as obvious as those of love. In history, while Fleming, Bell and the rest of the reiving clans declined, Scott alone flourished. Of course, in this masterly cui bono prosecution, Greig is not a wholly disinterested party. By emphasising Lord Scott’s role as Machiavellian victor, the tamer of the Borders’ heroic lawlessness, the re-teller slyly suggests that Langton’s tale is the suppressed truth behind the delicate ballad handed down by Scott’s famous descendant: a sort of literary counterpart to Andy Wightman’s searing indictment of Scotland’s landed classes, The Poor Had No Lawyers.

Yet Greig must be careful not to push this intimation to the point of explicit churlishness towards his great predecessor; after all, he acknowledges in his novel’s epigraph, in the words of Montaigne, one of Langton’s heroes, ‘I have gathered a garland of other men’s flowers, and nothing is mine but the cord that bines them’. He quotes the ballad in full before the novel opens, in snatches throughout – always, of course, in a version he owes to Scott, the version Scott himself called ‘an imperfect state’. To take Scott to task for the contents of that version is to risk inaccuracy as well as ingratitude. As ever Greig’s ingenious solution involves Langton - personally concerned in, not to mention responsible for, the whole incident, and understandably irked by the bowdlerisation of ‘the ballad-mongers’:

Fair Helen, chaste Helen…Tastes and times have changed to favour the respectable and douce, and rendered those days of quick-blooded men and women into something noble, picturesque and sexless. They do her a disservice. She was much more than fair and chaste.

Thus Langton rebukes both Drummond and his Caroline gentlemen, and Scott and his Romantic readers; but Greig’s own guiding spirit is more generous to Scott. In the stables of Crichton Castle and the corner of an inn in Southwark, Langton encounters the same theatrical ‘senior man’, ‘balding’, ‘quiet’, with ‘lustrous eyes’.

Something about him made one want to tell all, like a confession but without any judgement made at the end…His listening reminded me of Buccleuch, except that I sensed it was not earthly power that this man sought. Nor did he seem especially bent on heaven.

Speaking of heaven, Borges has a story about this same man once he got there:

…he found himself before God and he said: “I, who have been so many men in vain, want to be one man: myself.” The voice of God replied from a whirlwind: “Neither am I one self; I dreamed the world as you dreamed your work, my Shakespeare, and among the shapes of my dream are you, who, like me, are many persons—and none.”

For Scott to be placed, even obliquely, even ancestrally, even unfavourably in such a comparison is an elegant enough tribute from Greig to offset Harry Langton’s cavils.

[1] ‘A dismal season’, as Langton reluctantly renders it, before exclaiming ‘Ah, Robert Henrysoun, what a falling off is here!’

Wednesday, 27 November 2013

Unsuccessful application for cataloguer post at Peter Harrington




I have grown up aware of unusual and beautiful books, and spent most of my life reading them. Françoise Sagan remarks that general conversation with strangers is unnecessary, next to the more important questions, ‘Whom do you love? What are you reading?’ How convenient, then, if the answers to both coincide. I have never interpreted the adjective bookish as anything less than a high honour.

I like my reading, whether for pleasure or study, to be directed both by happy accident and specific curiosity. I am particularly interested – by now professionally so – in biographical questions; when I read English at Oxford, I did my best to evade academic theory, preferring the antiquarian pursuit of immersing myself in the lives and historical periods of writers, their friends, issue, relations, acquaintances, commercial, personal, political and amatory rivals, and other connections. These things seem to me both interesting in themselves and a prerequisite for developing an accurate ear for the language and idiom of particular authors. My postgraduate degree included courses in palaeography and bibliography – in particular, as it turned out, examining manuscripts by the courtier and verse translator Sir John Harington, the playwright Thomas Middleton, the Jacobite Bishop of Rochester, Francis Atterbury, and early editions of Shakespeare, Spenser, Ariosto and Tasso. I would value the opportunity to develop these skills by putting them to more practical use. I am used to concentrated work, absorbing and distilling large quantities of information. I have an eye for detail, and set great store by accuracy. I would have much to learn about the specifics of the book trade, but I am quick to master a new idiom and have had some cognate work experience assisting the cataloguers in the Old Masters department of Christies.

I am drawn to the Latin languages and can read and write French and Italian and speak them communicably. My spoken and written Spanish is much more basic, but I can read it. I developed a love of the classical languages and literature at school, and can still (with a little persistence) translate poetry, inscriptions, and tags in Latin and Greek. My amateur but intense emotional attachment to medieval literature and history, as well as some of my university work, gives me a foundation in Old and Middle French and English. I am also interested in historical and dialect Italian, and fairly conversant with the vernacular of Dante.

My historical and biographical interests are miscellaneous and have become, if anything, more so during and since university. Over the last two years I have been working on a life of the learned but popular medieval historian Sir Steven Runciman, a man famous for his ‘ability to ignore the conventional limits of time and space’, as one obituarist put it, and I stand by this catholic approach to the past: history as the true study of human beings, that should not be artificially simplified into movements and neat periods. Partly with this principle in mind, and partly for pleasure, I have found myself absorbing information from many different eras with little or no fixed, utilitarian objective in mind, but I would hope that working as a cataloguer for Peter Harrington would be a serendipitous way to put this magpie temperament to practical purpose.

My historiography is, academically speaking, adrift in a state prior to the Annales, but I am confident with the basics: Roman emperors and popes, Guelphs and Ghibellines, the names, dates, and wives of the Kings of France, England, and Scotland, the pronunciation of Wriothesley, the Civil War and who backed whom, the Dutch usurpation and its pragmatic, mercantilist aftermath. From the eighteenth century the past often seems to me more vividly resurrected via letters memoirs and the higher gossip: outstanding examples being Walpole, Creevey, and Greville. My attachment to and affinity for these genres extends in the twentieth century to wide reading and familiarity with the novels, memoirs, and letters of Evelyn Waugh, Nancy Mitford, Anthony Powell, Cyril Connolly, Barbara Skelton, Simon Raven, Hugh Trevor-Roper, Mary McCarthy, Muriel Spark, Iris Murdoch and so on in a quasi-Petrine succession, whose best contemporary representative is, I think, the novelist and historian James Buchan. While assisting the new OUP variorum edition of Evelyn Waugh, I found several unpublished Waugh letters in college archives, and am still engaged in similar, if more ambitious, work for my book on Steven Runciman. However, these recherché tastes do not by any means preclude a vigorous interest in current political debate and journalism: I keep up with the broadsheets and weekly periodicals and am au fait with current intellectual controversies.

Whenever chance has taken me in the direction of your bookshop – fortunately, of late, more and more – I have found a lot of pleasure and excitement there. I imagine you will have many more professionally qualified applications for your post, but if you are interested in taking a chance on someone who is hungry to learn and has a real appetite for the material, I hope that I would not disappoint you.

Friday, 24 May 2013

Sonnets from Sir Agravaine



1

My mother, Morgause, was a looker
So when King Arthur won the war
She merged the roles of spy and hooker
Of mother, sister, queen and whore.
She took her four boys from the Orkneys,
Went down on – if you trust the talk – knees,
Returned north with a brood of five,
My brother Mordred wombed, but live.

Her brother, au contraire, slept badly,
And dreamt of sharp and ominous things;
Serpents with legs, lions with wings -
Their rampant forms vexed the king sadly,
His couchant bed he left post-haste,
Rode off, more vigorous than chaste.


2

A heartsick king has but one notion
For putting conscience in its place
For shame and guilt, there is no potion
Can match the pleasures of the chase.

His knights and huntsmen came in plenty,
Pursued a hart whose tines were twenty,
But none equalled their young king’s force,
For Arthur’s spurs slew e’en his horse.

Thus forced to dally by a river,
Already pensive, he heard sounds:
The questing hues of thirty hounds –
Duly surpassèd with a slither,
As something crawled its way to slake
Its thirst. He pinched. He was awake.


3

But not for long – though not now dreaming,
My uncle Arthur by this time
So wearied beyond thought or deeming
Fell into rest that knew no chime.

Until rudely once more awoken
By a strange knight sans sign or token,
Who bellowed: ‘Have you seen my Beast?
Could you lend me a horse at least?’
The king’s groom drew up a fresh charger,
The stranger rustled it and left
My uncle furious and bereft,
But fortunate – the thief was larger.

(His name in truth was Pellinore,
Orkney’s sworn enemy in war.


4

He killed King Lot, who was our sire:
Both he and his son paid the price,
After – but, no, I mustn’t tire
You out with all this sordid vice.)

Back to King Arthur, still yet steedless,
Who understandably proved heedless
Of Merlin lecturing from disguise,
With words insufferably wise,
But when the snide sage was unmasked,
Now learnt with incremental dread
Of just who had been in his bed,
And got some hard truths quite unasked.

He asked his mother, Queen Igreyne,
For proof: he hoped for none, in vain.


5

Four sections full of combat later,
We find my uncle back on form,
Spirits recouped, he fears no traitor,
Feels no calm before no storm.
He’s exercised by just one matter –
quite far removed from Merlin’s patter –
The need to source a decent brand,
Since his sword shattered in his hand.

Arthur has heard of the best steel
From far Toledo, further still
The craft of Milan, edged to kill –
But Merlin has another deal
In mind, and harps upon the stock
Of an outlet beneath a loch.


6

The wizard’s tale was fey and wild –
Myself, I doubt it to this day.
I fear my uncle was beguiled
Whatever bards and jugglers say.

Some sing of pale limbs, taut and trembling
(The very savour of dissembling!)
Of fairy damsels, boats that glide
Without a pilot or a tide.

Suffice to say, the king was granted
A weapon with a diamond’s touch
A scabbard whose gemmed worth was such
To ransom emperors. Enchanted?
Perhaps it might as well have been,
But without doubt ‘richly beseen.’


7

Its pommel a pearl oceanic,
The hilt in stripes of beaten gold,
Its crossbar vivid and organic
With silvered sapphires untold.
Emeraldine lozenges surround
Sharp adamant leaf all around.
Its very name a precious hoard,
That Hebrew, Trojan, Grecian sword:
Your weird, whirred wooing yet I hear,
Excalibur – even now and nigh,
What recreants feel before they die,
Cut steel – Caliburn – I fear…
I fear to die? It is not just
That – to turn Orkney’s blood to rust.


8

At any rate, it pleased my uncle,
Became his sceptre and his sign.
Each several embedded carbuncle
Endeared it sweeter in his eyn.
It was a part and pact of power,
The thorn that must maintain the flower.
It was a rich blade, and a king
So armed, becomes a dangerous thing.

With May still in her youthful flourish
Even to Orkney came the law –
Crofter’s boy, queen’s son, spawn of whore,
All that on May-Day drew first nourish,
All these were subject to the state,
State and the sword, and no kind fate.


9

They put these May babes on a vessel
Down the grey waters of the Usk,
Several hundred, more or less – all
Nearer far to breast than rusk.

In high winds the ship brast asunder
Succumbed to sea-spray, cliffs and thunder
And, just perhaps, to fouler play.
So none of these bairns outlived May
(excepting one, my baby brother,
Caerleon-conceived, Kirkwall-born,
fostered by fishermen in scorn,
Mordred, whom no king’s crime could smother).

The people blamed Merlin the sage,
Forgave their king on grounds of age.


10

What of it then, this sword of magic,
The seal of a stainèd reign?
Say rather, vile fraud and tragic,
And fitted well to its refrain.
Mewed about in scams monastic,
Blunted, boasted and fantastic,
Sold then to sweeten regal pacts,
Tarnished in the harsh light of facts.
Looted, layered, and preserved,
In some long-forgotten suite,
Glassed in from any kind of feat,
Caliburn got what it deserved.

So far I’m obliged to endite.
Sir Agravaine of Orkney. Knight.

Thursday, 25 April 2013

Curriculum Mortis



The Muslim Council of Britain’s recent decision to attack Michael Gove’s proposed draft for a new history curriculum is not a surprising one. In isolation, it wouldn’t even be very worrying. As it is, though, it’s the latest in a series of disavowals, some more serious than others. Simon Schama, who had previously worked on the proposals, at once ostentatiously disowned the published form – the draft, he said, bore ‘no resemblance’ to the one he had helped to develop a month earlier. Then, on 13th March, came an extended criticism in the TLS from David Cannadine. Cannadine is both a serious historian, and untainted by association with the Richard J. Evans types who are determined to block any emphasis on narrative history. At first his criticisms seemed sensible enough, but pessimistic and unexciting; even small-c conservative. Without extra time in schools, he argued, history cannot gain ground significantly; the curriculum is neither here nor there. It was when he began to specify the problems with the draft that my disagreement turned inexorably into disbelief.

Surely Cannadine had somehow got the wrong end of the ruler? How could it be that six year olds were to be introduced to the subject of history in the form of abstract, worthy-sounding but in fact debatable concepts – ‘civilisation, monarchy, parliament, democracy’ – rather than simple and effective stories? And surely Gove – that William Wilberforce, that Olaudah Equiano of the Academies – believed in letting teachers determine which stories to tell, and pupils decide which to hear, and when? How could it be right – how could it be practicable – that, as Cannadine claimed, the draft’s slavish adherence to the dreaded Key Stages allowed children only to learn once, fleetingly, at some particular and arbitrary age, about ancient Greece, or the Crusades? Had Cannadine been assimilated by the opposing lobby the Education Secretary refers to without compromise as ‘The Blob’? But when I dug out the draft to check all was well, it proved all that Cannadine had warned, and worse.

The ‘narrative’ versus ‘themes’ history curriculum debate is probably as much about entertainment as politics – which is why I still think Gove’s policy, imaginatively implemented, has potential to be transformative, vote-winning as well as genuinely beneficial to the vital cause of interesting schoolchildren in history. The consistent success of stories, from the Bible to Rowling to Mantel, by way of any number of boxed set DVDs, indicates to me that there is a solid majority, otherwise without political allegiance, in favour of narrative history. Nevertheless, its opponents’ favourite line of attack is to slam it as ‘boring’, ‘rote-learning’. Gove’s most important task was to show them why they were wrong, and, on the basis of the deadly draft, he has failed in that task.

Hugh Trevor-Roper – inarguably one of the least boring of historians – once, like Disraeli and C.P. Snow before him, described this country as one made up of two worlds –
...on the one hand, the solemn, pompous, dreary, respectable Times-reading world, which hates elections (indeed, hates life) and thinks that everything should be left to the experts, the professionals, themselves; and, on the other hand, the gay, irreverent, genial, unpompous world which holds exactly opposite views, the world of the educated laity who do not see why they should be excluded from political matters because they are not politicians, nor from intellectual matters because they are not scholars…

The Coalition – that unexpected offspring of a loveless Establishment marriage – has always risked looking as if it belonged to the first camp. It is to Gove’s advantage and credit that he generally sounds like he comes from the second; the changeling child of Aberdonian fisherfolk, now turned journalistic swashbuckler. So why has he approved a plan so bereft of narrative excitement, a draft that struggles to placate and fails to persuade?

Let us take it stage by dreary Key Stage. KS 1 (for ages 5-7) is a peculiar cocktail of the patronising, the overweening and the inexact. A bullet point earnestly presses the importance of teaching what ‘before’ and ‘after’ mean. There follows the forbidding clutch of abstract ideas excoriated by Cannadine, the most totalitarian of which is probably ‘the concept of a nation’. Then there’s the SISA section – ‘Significant Individuals Such As.’ Various pairs of famous and virtuous beings follow, but nothing defines why precisely they qualify as famous or virtuous enough for the under-7s – and not once is their entertainment value considered of importance. The only good idea here is that places, events and worthies local to the school should be prioritised – though it does get one wondering about catchment areas for the glorious dead.

KS 2 (for ages 7-11) is, by contrast, exhaustingly full. It has evoked a universal cry of ‘How’ – how to teach and how to learn so much so fast. Some emphasis is a little odd – the Stone Age to the Celtic settlement is almost all pre-history. Isn’t the lesson that history, that stories, begin with and rely on written accounts important in itself? Neither are those, such as the Muslim Council of Britain, who complain of insularity and Anglocentrism mistaken; even France only staggers in once or twice, let alone Saladin or Averroes. But the main problem is that this incalculably rich and exciting saga – Roman Britain to Queen Anne – is under the current scheme snatched away, like Narnia or Philip Pullman’s shape-shifting daemons, with the onset of puberty.

KS 3 (11-14) is where the Goveite rigour really stiffens into rigor mortis. It reads in fact as if written during some unsteady collusion between Gove’s loyal henchmen and his sworn foes, veering about between Clive of India and the Tolpuddle Martyrs. This conveys not so much political neutrality as narrative incoherence. Again, there’s too much too fast, but with two centuries rather than two millennia under discussion, much of it is unlikely to be very gripping (‘the impact of mass literacy and the Elementary Education Act’, dully post-modern; ‘Lloyd-George’s coalition’, worthy of Hansard.) A sense that Gove is for some reason banking on Scottish independence permeates these hurried plans; how otherwise would he expect to get away with blandly ascribing Adam Smith to ‘the Enlightenment in England’? The draft adds insult to its self-inflicted injuries by fetishizing 1989 as a stop-date, precisely as 1066 and All That – in jest – mummified 1918 as the End of History.

But I still believe in Gove – in what he is doing, and that it can be done. He must start by pulling a repeat trick – consigning this draft to educational history rather than historical education. When the curriculum emerges, poor Simon Schama must again be startled. The transformation will be entire. For early history will now be taught somewhat like early science. First will come long years of stories, lovingly and luxuriously told. It hardly matters what they are; the Trojan War and King Arthur will do very nicely, as long as they are well told. Then, fewer, swifter and still more exciting, will be the years of revelation – that all these stories, that all stories, are lies, though they contain truths. That despite and because of being lies, they are all-important. And that historians, teachers, pupils, and politicians are all entitled to engage in the humanising habit of confecting their own stories.

Tuesday, 19 March 2013

'missed moment' for the Telegraph...WORTHLESS MEN



‘Somewhat mechanical,’ comments Montague Beckwith, the shell-shocked officer in Andrew Cowan’s First World War novel Worthless Men, of his suffragist sisters’ minds, ‘though exceptionally well-oiled.’ The same faint praise might be applied to the story at large. Cowan confides in an afterword that ‘the origins of this novel lie in some interviews I conducted in my mid-twenties while setting up an oral history archive in Norwich’, and this daunting ancestry can show. Details and observations emerge with more insistence than sprezzatura.

The novel’s structure is meticulous, its apparatus unstartling. The present, apparently become the natural tense of government for historical fiction, stays on. The old modernist vogue for Aristotelian unities keeps us in one market day and one town, waiting for the Tommies (and cows) to come home. Restrictions of grammar, time and place are relieved by the freewheeling recollections of five characters; three members of the younger generation, and (featuring more occasionally) two of their parents. At one point we meet a factory-hand called, plausibly enough, Mr. Rivett, and Worthless Men is indeed a thing of bolts and rivets. In wartime, after all, every component matters.

The first and last mind’s eye the reader experiences in Worthless Men is that of Walter Barley, a small, plucky, industrious lad, enlisted much too young (we find out why, slowly). Cowan can be maddeningly close with information, but he’s relatively free with Walter’s situational USP. From the moment Walter, missing in action, witnesses his mother and sister discussing his (just) possible return, it’s fairly clear that, as they can’t see him or hear his interruptions, he must already be beyond this life. Yet Cowan is teasingly physical in describing this ghost, ‘lice-ridden’ from the moment of his materialisation, his pockets full of ‘fluff and tobacco strands’, his fingers wincing at the still-sharp quill of a carefully preserved white feather.

Walter is a kind of everyman’s Hamlet, his tragedy already run. His father is an absent drunk, and he believes his mother to be carrying on with the local butcher. Cowan convinces us through the son to (mis)judge the mother accordingly, while the butcher’s trade permits reiterative echoes of Wilfred Owen. One notion neither Walter nor the novel channels is spiritualism, the craze that was to riddle the post-war bereaved. Although Worthless Men is a work of social history quite as much as it is of fiction, Cowan offers the presence of ghosts as an exclusively literary device, rather than a socio-historical phenomenon.

Perhaps he felt his novel had space to examine only one discredited pseudo-science, for both its plot and characters are steeped in discussion of eugenics. The title Worthless Men itself comes from a monograph by Gerard Oram, which makes the point that First World War private soldiers were executed overwhelmingly more often than officers because of institutional military disdain for ‘working-class stock’. Cowan’s two eugenic theorists are the officer, Beckwith, and the pharmacist, Dobson. Beckwith is a particularly articulate voice but also the least nuanced character; a rapist and murderer, a proto-fascist, and, of course, a gentleman. The closest thing he has to a positive human quality is despair. Dobson, domestically a pathetic and pompous tyrant, but an indispensable, informed medical resort for the city’s poor, is more interesting. His inseparable enthusiasms for contraception, abortion, and eugenics provide an unsettling comparison to contemporary orthodoxies and heresies.

The story’s real battlefield is Gertie Dobson, who acts both as Walter’s belle dame sans merci and Beckwith’s would-be Tess Durbeyfield. Brought up as the Dobson marriage’s daughter, her heritage proves to be more complicated, in a twist that crossbreeds romance and eugenics. Her first name would appear to be borrowed from Joyce’s lovely cripple, desirable and repellent, perfect and flawed. This Gertie’s flaw is backwardness, indeed near-imbecility by Dobson’s and Beckwith’s standards. But her moral innocence, which allows her, for example, to treat her father’s theories as harmless peculiarities, comes as an attractive relief.

Cowan keeps the Beckwith family, the area’s seigneurial dynasty, mainly in the background, while getting them just right. They are new money, chapel, Liberal, suffragist and insufferable, providing employment for all, and - in a gradual unspooling with gruesome consequences for the denouement - barbed wire for the trenches.